(92 & 93) Production Notes

Like most people, my musical tastes were really cemented in my teens/early twenties. It’s been over a decade now, and I’ve kinda been worried that my music selection for the podcast has been dating me. NIN, Tool, all the second-wave screamo, and most recently Live and Garbage – it’s all from the mid-90s to early-00s. Even Catch That Goblin is from the mid-90s demo scene. This was on my mind when choosing the new HPMoR theme. Yes, the theme is changing, since the mischievous romp of Catch That Goblin is no longer thematically appropriate. I wanted a song that conveyed a sense of mourning, yet also a determination to continue and ultimately triumph.

I had one immediately, but it was from that same time period and I wanted something closer to the present day, so I discarded it. The first alternate option to present itself was Foxy Shazam’s “Oh Lord”, which is freakin’ awesome, and pretty new. It has the mournfulness and the soldiering-on despite loss in it, and a tone of overcoming adversity. But the lyrics do strongly suggest putting trust in a father/mentor and accepting that things will be alright, which is very counter to the MoR theme of Nihil Supernum. No good.

Second option was “Marchin On” by OneRepublic, which has that determination and triumph to it, and has the good fortune of having gained popularity at the same time the last Rowling Potter movie was released, so there are a bunch of fan videos on YouTube showing poignant moments from Potter movies over the music of Marchin On. As such it’s likely there’s already a lot of emotional connection between that song and HP for a lot of people. Unfortunately there isn’t very much on the mourning side of things, and double-unfortunately I never really connected with the song so it doesn’t hold any emotional weight for me. And this is my podcast, so dammit, I want something I find personally meaningful in the theme!

So I went back to my first pick, which I had initially discarded. “Welcome to the Black Parade” by My Chemical Romance. It’s an awesome song with great vocals and lyrics, and music that starts with mourning and ends in exultation. And the song is literally about a boy who feels a responsibility to save the world mourning the death of a female friend but promising to carry on regardless, in memory of her. Is there any song more perfectly suited for the final act of HPMoR? Maybe – but this is the one I like best.


Every now and then I mention stories I like. This one struck my fancy – Ancient gods in modern settings, non-neurotypical protagonist, smart people thinking through the implications of things, and a love story. A Plant (Whose Name is Destroyed) (also available in audio!)

Bookmark the permalink.


  1. The second the music faded in this chapter I had to come to the site to congratulate you on a excellent choice in music! I loved tool and nin but this new intro just feels so right for the current mood of the story.
    I have been binge listening to this podcast in the car, at home and while sitting in physiotherapy lol.
    You make it so easy to listen to. All your extra voices really make the story come to life.
    I stopped reading after lesswrong went on a hiatus shortly after the Stanford experiment and recently realized i had alot to catch up on. When I found your podcast I was very happy and very impressed with the quality

    Thank you for your efforts in this podcast!

  2. Your podcast (and the story) is so awesome!! and now that I’m up to date, I wondered if I would ever find another fiction podcast near as good. I was looking on your blog for suggestions, but didn’t find any, but now I just found one here. Thanks :-)

  3. I cried most with this podcast — you bring to life this story in way that is far more viscerel than words alone can accomplish.

    And, of course, yours has become the voice of my Inner Harry Potter… I wonder for how many others that is also true! Crazy thought.

  4. It was the perfect song! Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.